Audio CD review:
Madonna - American Pie, Pt. 1

Madonna - American Pie, Pt. 1

Band: Madonna Title: American Pie, Pt. 1 Rating: Release Date: 07 March, 2000 Media: Audio CD Tracks: 1: American Pie (Album Version) 2: American Pie (Richard Humpty Vission Radio Mix) 3: American Pie (Victor Calderone Filter Dub Mix) 4: American Pie (Richard Humpty Vission Visits

Customer Reviews Have Faith Most of the "bad" reviews obviously comes from "older" people who find it difficult to adapt to the natural progression of music. It is with great shock and dissapointment that I read some of the scathing reviews here relating to this song. This is Madonna's interpretation of the song, it is NOT Don McLean's version and never will be. Deal with it. If Don McLean can praise Madonna for her version of this song (which he has), why can't some of the other "sour" reviewers do the same? No one is asking them to buy this single, no one is asking them to even listen to it and no one is forcing them to like it. Their subjective, narrow-minded and self involved (a very American trait) views should be kept to themselves and not try to force their point of view onto other people. The world of music should be a democratic, let each and every one of us decide what music we like or don't. Getting back to this release; it is the German 4 track version with the album version and some remixes. Never having been a fan of Victor Calderone, this trend continues here. The other remixes are not too bad, I kind of like Richard "Humpty's" versions, they're fun and energetic. . LISTEN TO ME RIGHT NOW! Believe me- it's worth it!. Don't you dare buy this butchered remake! Get the original by Don McLean. Why? She left out so much that it's not completed. What was Madonna thinking when she attempted to remake american Pie? She did it no justice at all, and she lost all of the meaning. She totally killed it, and I don't understand how people can accually like it. . You can see a complete list of all Madonna discography, or go back to the Madonna tabs